Welcome to my blog of Red Dot vs Holographic Sights.
As a shooter, whether you are a hunter, a law enforcement officer, or a gun enthusiast, one of the most important things to consider is the type of sight you will use. Two popular types of sights are red dot sights and holographic sights.
These sights have unique features that make them suitable for different purposes. In this blog post, we will compare red dot vs holographic sights and help you choose which one is right for you.
What is Red Dot Sight
Red dot sights are the most popular type of sight used by shooters. They are compact, lightweight, and simple to use. They work by projecting a red dot onto a lens in front of the shooter’s eye, which is used as the point of aim. Here are some advantages and disadvantages of using red dot sights.
Advantages
- Easy to use and maintain
- Light and compact
- Works well in low-light conditions
- It has a wide field of view
Disadvantages
- Limited battery life
- It can have a small field of view depending on the model
- Can be affected by parallax
- Limited magnification options
What Is Holographic Sight
Holographic sights are similar to red dot sights in their function. They work by projecting a holographic reticle onto a lens, which is the point of aim. Unlike red dot sights, they use a laser to create the reticle, which makes them more expensive. Here are some advantages and disadvantages of using holographic sights:
Advantages
- Unlimited eye relief
- It can be used with both eyes open
- It has a wider field of view than red dot sights
- The reticle is clearer and easier to see than red dot sights
Disadvantages
- Expensive
- Can be affected by parallax
- Requires more battery power than red dot sights
Comparison – Red Dot vs Holographic Sights
1. Size and weight
Red Dot Sight
Red dot sights are known for their compact and lightweight design. The size and weight can vary depending on the specific model and brand, but red dot sights are generally small and easy to maneuver. Most red dot sights weigh less than 10 ounces and are less than 4 inches long.
One of the advantages of the smaller size is that they can be mounted on various firearms, including handguns, shotguns, and rifles, without adding too much weight or bulk to the gun. This makes them a great option for those who need a lightweight and portable firearm for hunting or tactical situations.
Holographic Sight
Holographic sights tend to be slightly larger and heavier than red dot sights. The weight can vary depending on the specific model and brand, but holographic sights are usually around 11 ounces or more and can be up to 5 inches in length.
While the larger size and weight can make them less versatile for certain applications, the added size can also provide additional benefits, such as a wider field of view and a larger reticle. This can be helpful for those who need to shoot at longer ranges or in situations where accuracy is crucial.
Winner: Red Dot Sights
2. Reticle
Another important factor to consider when choosing between a red dot sight and a holographic sight is the reticle – the pattern or design that is used to aim at a target. Here’s a closer look at how the two types of sights compare in terms of their reticles:
Red Dot Sight
Red dot sights typically have a simple, illuminated dot as the reticle. The size of the dot can vary depending on the specific model and brand but is usually between 1 and 4 MOA (minute of angle). Some red dot sights also offer the option to change the shape of the reticle to a crosshair or other pattern.
One advantage of the simple dot reticle is that it allows for quick and easy target acquisition, making red dot sights ideal for close to mid-range shooting. However, some shooters may find the need for additional reticle features limiting in certain situations.
Holographic Sight
Holographic sights, on the other hand, typically offer a more complex reticle design that includes multiple aiming points, circles, and crosshairs. This allows for greater precision and accuracy at longer ranges. Some holographic sights also offer the ability to switch between different reticle designs to suit different shooting scenarios.
Additionally, some holographic sights also offer a feature called “zero shift,” which ensures that the reticle stays aligned with the firearm, even after being bumped or dropped. This can be particularly useful for law enforcement or military applications where firearms are subject to rigorous use.
Overall, while red dot sights offer a simple and easy-to-use reticle design, holographic sights offer more versatility and precision with their multi-point reticles. The choice of reticle ultimately depends on the shooter’s specific needs and preferences.
Winner: Tie
3. Magnification & Power
Red Dot Sight
Red dot sights do not offer magnification or power. They are designed to provide a clear and precise aiming point without the need for magnification. Red dot sights are ideal for close to mid-range shooting scenarios, where the target is relatively close to the shooter. They are also popular among shooters who need to acquire targets quickly, such as in tactical or home defense situations.
Holographic Sight
Holographic sights offer some level of magnification or power, but typically not as much as traditional magnifying scopes. Some holographic sights offer a fixed magnification level, such as 1x or 2x, while others offer variable magnification levels. Holographic sights are ideal for mid-range shooting scenarios, where the target is farther away from the shooter. They are also popular among shooters who require greater precision and accuracy.
Winner: Holographic Sights
4. Battery life
Red Dot Sight
Red dot sights typically use LED technology to illuminate the reticle, which is energy-efficient and allows for longer battery life. Most red dot sights offer a battery life of anywhere from 1,000 to 50,000 hours, depending on the specific model and brand. Some red dot sights also feature an automatic shut-off function, which helps to conserve battery life when the sight is not in use.
One thing to keep in mind is that the battery life of a red dot sight can be affected by the brightness setting. The higher the brightness level, the faster the battery will drain. However, even at the highest brightness level, most red dot sights offer battery life that is measured in thousands of hours.
Holographic Sight
Holographic sights typically use more advanced technology to illuminate the reticle, which can be more power-hungry than LED technology. As a result, holographic sights generally have shorter battery life than red dot sights. However, most holographic sights still offer a battery life of anywhere from 500 to 1,000 hours, depending on the specific model and brand. Some holographic sights also feature an automatic shut-off function to conserve battery life.
One advantage of holographic sights is that they often have a battery compartment that is easily accessible and can be changed quickly in the field. Some red dot sights, on the other hand, require the removal of the sight from the firearm in order to change the battery.
Winner: Red Dot Sights
5. Build Quality
Red Dot Sight
Red dot sights are generally constructed from high-quality materials, such as aluminum or titanium. They are designed to be lightweight yet durable, with the ability to withstand the recoil of a firearm. The lenses of a red dot sight are often coated with anti-reflective materials to improve visibility and reduce glare.
One potential downside of red dot sights is that they may not be as rugged or durable as holographic sights. Some red dot sights may be susceptible to damage from water or impact, which can affect their performance.
Holographic Sight
Holographic sights are typically constructed from high-quality materials, such as aluminum. They are designed to be rugged and durable, with the ability to withstand harsh weather conditions and heavy recoil. Holographic sights often feature a sealed design to protect against water, dust, and debris.
One advantage of holographic sights is that they are often more durable than red dot sights, thanks to their rugged construction and advanced design. This makes them a popular choice among hunters, military personnel, and law enforcement officers.
Winner: Holographic Sight
6. Close quarters battle
Red Dot Sight
Red dot sights are ideal for CQB scenarios, thanks to their ability to provide a clear and precise aiming point at close range. Red dot sights are typically designed to offer a wide field of view, which allows shooters to quickly acquire targets and maintain situational awareness.
Holographic Sight
Holographic sights can also be effective in CQB scenarios, but they may not be as well-suited for this shooting as red dot sights. Holographic sights are typically designed to offer greater precision and accuracy at longer ranges, which can make them less ideal for close-range shooting.
However, some holographic sights are designed to offer a wider field of view, which can be helpful in CQB scenarios. In addition, holographic sights are often rugged and durable, which can make them a good choice for tactical or military use.
Winner: Red Dot Sights
7. Astigmatism
Astigmatism is a common condition that affects the way people see light, causing blurriness, distortion, and other visual problems. Here’s a closer look at how red dot sights and holographic sights compare in terms of their suitability for people with astigmatism.
Red Dot Sights
Red dot sights can be a good choice for people with astigmatism, as they typically feature a simple reticle that is easy to see and aim with. The dot is usually a small, simple shape, which can help to reduce the effects of astigmatism.
However, some people with astigmatism may still experience blurriness or distortion when looking through a red dot sight. In these cases, it may be helpful to try different types of red dot sights to find one that works well with your particular type of astigmatism.
Holographic Sight
Holographic sights can also be a good choice for people with astigmatism, as they typically feature a more complex reticle that can be easier to see and aim with than a simple dot. The reticle in a holographic sight is created by projecting a holographic image onto a lens, which can help to reduce the effects of astigmatism.
Winner: Holographic Sights
8. Hunting
When it comes to hunting, both red dot sights and holographic sights can be effective depending on the type of hunting and the shooter’s preferences. Here’s a closer look at how the two types of sights compare in terms of their suitability for hunting:
Red Dot Sight
Red dot sights can be a good choice for hunting when quick target acquisition is important, such as when hunting small game or birds. Red dot sights offer a wide field of view and a clear aiming point, which can help hunters quickly and accurately aim at fast-moving targets.
Holographic Sight
Holographic sights can also be effective for hunting, particularly when greater accuracy and precision are needed, such as when hunting larger games at longer ranges. Holographic sights can be helpful for hunters who need to adjust for bullet drop or windage.
Some holographic sights feature adjustable magnification, which can be helpful for hunters who need to zoom in on targets at longer ranges. However, holographic sights are typically bulkier and heavier than red dot sights, making them less suitable for hunters who need to move quickly or quietly in the field.
Winner: Tie
9. Night Vision
Red Dot Sight
Red dot sights can be used with night vision devices, such as clip-on devices that attach to the front of the sight. Red dot sights can provide a clear aiming point in low-light conditions when used with night vision devices.
However, it’s important to choose a red dot sight that is compatible with your specific night vision device, as not all sights are compatible with all devices. In addition, red dot sights may have limitations in terms of range and accuracy when used with night vision devices, particularly in very low-light conditions.
Holographic Sight
Holographic sights can also be used with night vision devices and may offer some advantages over red dot sights in terms of their compatibility and performance. Some holographic sights are designed specifically for use with night vision devices and may offer features such as adjustable brightness levels and reticle patterns optimized for use in low-light conditions.
Winner: Tie
10. Price and affordability
When it comes to price and affordability, red dot sights are generally more affordable than holographic sights.
Red Dot Sight
Red dot sights are typically more affordable than holographic sights, depending on the quality and features of the sight.
Holographic Sight
Holographic sights are generally more expensive than red dot sights. Higher-end models can cost several thousand dollars, depending on the features and quality of the sight.
Winner: Red Dot Sights
Which one to choose?
Choosing between a red dot sight and a holographic sight depends on your shooting needs and preferences. :
Purpose: Consider what you’ll be using the sight for. A red dot sight may be a good choice if you’re primarily using it for close-quarters combat or fast-paced shooting. A holographic sight may be a better option if you need greater precision and accuracy for longer-range shooting.
Budget: Red dot sights are generally more affordable than holographic sights, so a red dot sight may be a more practical choice if you’re on a budget.
Eye Relief: If you wear glasses or have other vision issues, a holographic sight may be a better option due to its long eye relief, which can help reduce eye strain and discomfort.
Battery life: Consider the battery life of the sight, particularly if you’ll be using it for extended periods. Holographic sights typically have shorter battery life than red dot sights, so a red dot sight may be a better option if battery life is a concern.
Shooting environment: If you are shooting in low-light conditions, consider a sight with night vision capabilities or one compatible with night vision devices.
Overall, both red dot and holographic sights have advantages and disadvantages. It’s important to consider your specific shooting needs and preferences before deciding. If possible, trying out both types of sights to see which one feels more comfortable and natural for you is a good idea.
Top 5 best holographic sights
Here are some of the best holographic sights currently available in the market:
1. EOTech 512 Holographic Sight
This is one of the most popular and reliable holographic sights, with a wide 68 MOA ring reticle and a 1 MOA center dot. It has a rugged build and long battery life, making it suitable for a range of shooting activities.
2. Vortex Razor AMG UH-1 Holographic Sight
This holographic sight offers a large, clear-sight picture and a versatile EBR-CQB reticle. Its durable construction and long battery life make it popular for tactical and competition shooting.
3. EOTech EXPS3 Holographic Sight
This compact and lightweight sight has a wide 68 MOA ring reticle and a 1 MOA center dot, making it easy to acquire targets quickly. Its quick-detach mount allows for easy installation and removal.
4. Sightmark Ultra Shot M-Spec
This holographic sight offers a durable carbon fiber construction and multiple reticle options, including a crosshair and a circle dot. It is designed for fast target acquisition and has a long battery life.
5. Holosun HS510C Holographic Sight
This sight offers a unique open-frame design and a versatile reticle that can switch between a 2 MOA dot, a 65 MOA circle, or a circle-dot combination. It has a solar cell backup and a long battery life, making it a reliable choice for a variety of shooting activities.
Top 5 best Red Dot Sights
Here are some of the best red dot sights currently available in the market:
1. Trijicon RMR Type 2
This is a top-of-the-line red dot sight known for its durability and reliability. It features a clear 3.25 MOA dot reticle and is suitable for various shooting activities, including law enforcement and military applications.
2. Holosun HS507C-X2
This red dot sight offers multiple reticle options, including a 2 MOA dot, a 32 MOA circle, or a circle-dot combination. It has a long battery life and is suitable for various firearms.
3. Vortex Venom
This compact, lightweight sight has a clear 3 MOA dot reticle and a durable build. It offers multiple brightness settings and long battery life, making it suitable for a variety of shooting activities, including hunting and competition shooting.
4. Burris Fastfire III
This red dot sight offers a clear 3 MOA dot reticle and a compact design. It has a long battery life and is suitable for various firearms, including handguns and shotguns.
5. Aimpoint PRO
This is a rugged and durable red dot sight designed for law enforcement and military use. It features a clear 2 MOA dot reticle and a long battery life, making it suitable for a range of shooting activities.
Conclusion
Both holographic and red dot sights are popular options for shooters looking for a quick and accurate sighting system. Holographic sights offer a larger viewing window and are better suited for long-range shooting, while red dot sights are more compact and lightweight and are ideal for close-quarters combat and quick target acquisition.
Choosing between the two ultimately comes down to personal preference and intended use. Shooters looking for a wider field of view and more precise aiming may prefer holographic sights, while those looking for a smaller, lighter option may prefer red dot sights. Regardless of your choice, both allow for quick and accurate target acquisition.
Now that you have an idea of the different types of sights available and their features, you can decide which one is best suited to your needs.
Good luck!
FAQs
What’s the difference between a holographic sight and a red dot sight?
A holographic sight uses a laser to project a reticle onto a holographic window, while a red dot sight uses an LED to project a dot reticle onto a lens.
What firearms can I use a holographic or red dot sight on?
Holographic and red dot sights can be used on rifles, shotguns, and handguns, among other firearms.
What’s the battery life of a typical holographic or red dot sight?
Battery life varies, but most holographic and red dot sights offer several thousand hours of battery life on a single battery.
Can I use a magnifier with a holographic or red dot sight?
Yes, many holographic and red dot sights can be used with a magnifier for additional magnification.
How do I zero my holographic or red dot sight?
You’ll need to adjust the windage and elevation settings to zero your sight until the reticle is aligned with your target. It’s important to follow the manufacturer’s instructions and ensure you’re using the right ammunition and shooting technique.